2 Comments

99 Problems

The daily struggles of urban living as a quadriplegic explained one by one. It's so much more than not being able to find a parking space.

What Breaking My Neck Taught Me About White Privilege

P

I created this image via Photoshop. However, the original was a photo taken by Elliot Erwitt in 1950 in North Carolina, USA, and contained the words “White” and “Colored.” It represents the injustice of segregation of black and white people in America during this time, just sixty-plus short years ago.

America’s political disparity seems to be at an all time high right now. I’d say this happens after every four-year election cycle, except this time it feels different. People have been spiteful and unkind to each other, more than ever before. Trump supporters are celebrating having won the Senate, House and Presidency trifecta, happily high-fiving and giving both coasts the middle finger, while Clinton supporters are weeping and simultaneously marching through the streets prepared to set the world afire. In full disclosure, I relate to the latter. I was with her. I still am with her. But that’s not what this post is about. I’m self aware enough to know that simply sharing the agony I felt after Hillary’s loss will not create the change I want to see. So instead of documenting my tears, I want to share my unique position as a white privileged person, who is also a disabled minority, living in our deeply diverse but underrepresented country, with hopes to awaken compassion and understanding for why all of us could benefit from using our privilege.

I broke my neck doing a trampoline stunt at Sea World Orlando back in the fall of 1998, just as I was peaking as an adventurous 20-something grabbing the world by the balls. For the sake of time, I won’t share any of the details of that catastrophic day, the months of grueling therapy to come after and years spent adjusting (because they can be found here and here), but I will catch you up on what you need to know about me for now. I am a 38-year-old former gymnast paralyzed from the chest down, with partial use of my arms, little dexterity in my hands and not much to work with from the nipples down. For those who like medical jargon, I’m a C5-6 quadriplegic, sensory incomplete, which means I had no chance of any physical recovery, though I have regained some sensations over time (Not much, and mostly just pain. Go figure). I’ve lived this way for the past eighteen years (and I mean exactly eighteen years, because today, November 16 is my injury anniversary date), and to make up for what my body cannot provide me, I use a power wheelchair daily so that I can participate in society as actively as possible.

Having a disability has taught me a lot. It’s taught me to appreciate the little things in life, like beautiful sunsets and the touch of friends. It’s taught me not to take one day for granted, as they are gifts, not promises. It’s taught me how to be a better problem solver, and that anything is possible if you take long enough to think about how to make it happen. And uniquely, it’s given me the perspective to understand the meaning of white privilege and its power by allowing me to see the world from a different lens.

As a white woman, I obviously cannot know what it’s like to be a racial minority living in America. I do, however, know what it’s like to be a minority trying to survive in a world not made for me (which is what unites all minorities given our country was founded and continually governed by mostly straight, white men). Some of my personal challenges as a wheelchair user include avoiding stairs, dodging cracked sidewalks, searching for ramped curbs, staying clear of narrow doorways, finding sinks with leg room underneath, preferring tables that aren’t too low, appreciating mirrors that aren’t too high, using bathrooms that are too small, finding parking with enough space, remaining hopeful for elevators, even if inconveniently located, and then hoping the elevators are in service. The list goes on and on. I’ll call these microaggressions, because they’re not obstacles or problems that are necessarily life threatening, but more like small annoyances that become torturous over time. My husband describes it as “like death by a thousand paper cuts,” which I find funny because it’s painstakingly accurate (He’s not disabled, although he understands because he’s married to my adversity).

By now some of you must be thinking, “Hey! Not so fast. I thought we had laws for that!” And you’re right. Twenty-five years ago the Americans with Disabilities Act (or ADA) was created to protect those with disabilities by legislating certain public property guidelines so that accessibility was more inclusive. However, it’s also true that these laws only eased burdens, not resolved them completely. I can attest to the overall shift for a more accessible world and its successes, because I have seen and felt the changes over time (the ADA had only been effect for seven years when I initially became a wheelchair user, so we have grown together). But still, we cannot be complacent. There is still much more work to do (ahem, New York City, I’m looking at you), because no matter what the size of a daily struggle, when it’s compounded over a lifetime, like many minority microaggressions are, they become set backs that reinforce inequality.

Another way in which minorities are segregated from most are the extra responsibilities and social obligations that come with being “different.” In my case, it’s explaining my disability repeatedly each day, openly and pleasantly every time, even when I don’t feel like it, because not doing so can have catastrophic consequences. As we all know, first impressions mean everything, and mine in particular will create or shape a world view of an entire demographic. So I must stay diligent and represent myself with care, always, if for no other reason but to ease future encounters for my fellow wheelchair users. This includes being pro-active, taking time to field questions about political correctness, re-telling my origin story, educating curious children, constantly defining my personal space, communicating what violates that personal space, and doing whatever is needed to pacify the time or diffuse a potentially uncomfortable situation—for them of course, not me (My feelings are null and void until their assessment of my character is over).

With that being said (because I actually don’t mind sharing my life story obviously), I promote this without trying to create hyperawareness or more sensitivity, but instead just to make my point that minorities are tasked in ways that others aren’t. Which brings me to the biggest insult of being a minority—flat out rejection.

If you’re a human being with a beating heart, you know nothing can be more violating than alienation. There have been times that I’ve shown up to a place, even after being personally invited and encouraged with a “you’ll be fine” and “it’ll work out,” only to find out I wasn’t fine (I became the center of attention unwillingly), it didn’t work out (there were stairs galore), and then some in attendance became outraged by the lack access (my literal representation of inequality and injustice, even if unintentional, can ruin a good time for all, even those not directly effected). Isolation from a minority perspective is more than awkward, uncomfortable, or embarrassing—it can cut into the soul so deeply, it leaves scars in the form of anxiety and apprehension for next time. And there will always be a next time. Because that’s what happens when you live in a world that doesn’t reflect your perspective—your needs are left out and then you’re chastised for it.

So that’s why it’s absolutely essential we look inside our selves to find ways in which we are privileged, and then apply our privilege to others who are not. And if you happen to be a white, straight man living in America, this means using your privilege (and the fact that most of all government is represented by your specific perspective) to support, protect, and encourage all minority groups until our public offices reflect their voices, too. Because to embrace white privilege is not to be insulted or told your problems don’t exist, it’s to acknowledge inequality exists. And we know inequality exists because imagine this:

Imagine I started a campaign dedicated to exposing the difficulties of living with a disability, a world much like I have described to you already. Imagine the inspiration of my campaign: a fellow wheelchair user innocently and tragically killed while crossing the street by a driver who denies any guilt and takes no accountability. I can see with my own eyes that this death was unnecessary. And I think about how easily it could have been me, not him.

Imagine my fear.
Imagine my passion.
Imagine my anger.

Imagine I call up my friends and loop them into my cause. Imagine we take to the streets, both real and virtual, in an attempt to create awareness—not only for this particular wheelchair user but for other wheelchair users as well—because we do not want another wheelchair user to die in vain, and also because we want to create a tangible community to heal and grieve this horrific loss of life that has touched us so deeply.

Imagine how badly I want this message to be heard.
Imagine my heart racing, beating wildly and rapidly, every time I must cross the street.
Imagine me wanting to take action.

Imagine me wanting to scream louder than ever before, “Hey World! I’m here, too. My life matters! DISABLED LIVES MATTER!”

And then imagine, instead of acceptance or compassion or open ears or open hearts or open minds, I’m met with hostility and this disqualifying statement:

NO. ALL LIVES MATTER.

It wouldn’t happen. It simply wouldn’t. But that’s what happened to Alecia Garza, Opal Tometi and Patrisse Cullor, the courageous and beautiful women who founded the Black Lives Matter (or BLM) movement in honor of Trayvon Martin, a 17-year old black boy who was murdered for walking down the street of his neighborhood. And I find it unacceptable and heart-wrenching (because of course all lives matter. That was the entire point of the BLM movement to begin with).

To put this all in perspective, it’s rare that I’m ever shut out or denied by anyone with out a heart-felt “I’m sorry,” and so I consider myself a “lucky” minority. I honestly can’t fathom how other minorities survive this same world while also under attack by their peers, because frankly, I cherish the kindness of strangers.

So, join me.
Join me in using whatever privilege you can muster to show compassion when others do not.
Because after all, isn’t it our American privilege to do so anyways?

2 Responses to “What Breaking My Neck Taught Me About White Privilege”

  1. Dallas says:

    Your article was thought provoking. I can’t compare our struggles because you would have me beat. I can’t compare my struggles to those of my family that lived through slavery and the Jim Crow laws because they lived through a much more difficult time. We’re similar in that you probably represent all people with spinal cord injuries particularly when people don’t interact with people with spinal cord injuries. We’re different in that for me it’s only other people that remind me that I’m different. It’s sad but I have not fully embraced being different because if I had I would have fully embraced every part of me that’s different. My hair is what’s left. Isn’t it surprising what we all take for granted?

    All in all, the problem is not the barrier but the failure to seek your own solution for getting around the barrier.

    • Jana Waring says:

      Hi Dallas.

      I hear you. Thank you for taking the time read and comment on my blog. Struggles are struggles, and I’d take physical struggles over emotional struggles any day. They’re simply easier to identify and overcome. Overall, I think I do a pretty good job pushing boundaries and mowing over barriers. But I’m also aware it’s not as easy for others. I hope you do find a way to embrace your “differences” because I’ve found out overtime that being “different” can be a good thing. In my case, my differences have either become strengths or pushed me to have strength. Take care. There are a lot of people who want to know your story, too. <3 -J. Helms

Leave a Reply